If
you like Christmas tradition, thank Dickens.
If you like Christmas dinner, thank the South.
If you like biscuits, thank heavens you don’t
have to make them the old way.
However, if you do want to serve old-time beaten biscuits
this holiday season, get out the ax now and find yourself a
solid oak tree. You will need to fell the tree and plane the
stump before you prepare the Christmas turkey.
The invention of modern Christmas traditions
began with Charles Dickens, who wrote a new Christmas story
every year.
The most
famous of them conjures up family, home and occasion, which
Clemson University historian Alan Grubb notes are familiar
elements of our holidays today. The enlightened Scrooge of “A
Christmas Carol” responds to his newfound generosity
by buying food and joining his nephew’s family for Christmas
dinner.
If a nod from Dickens inspired Americans to serve a big holiday
dinner, it was the South that taught this country what to eat
and how to serve it, according to Grubb, who uses old cookbooks
to research history.
“Even in Colonial times, the South had a reputation
for good food and elaborate tables,” according to Grubb,
who says that old cookbooks are more than just recipes. They
were guidebooks with advice on etiquette, child rearing, medicine,
household hints and marriage. “The South was an agrarian
society, and Christmas also was hog-killing time, so it was
a time of plenty.”
Southern cooking was so revered that books on the subject
were available all over the country. Some of them were written
by non-southerners, but all of them were written by women and
for women.
The kitchen was the domain of the woman, often
the family matriarch, and a holiday was her big moment. The
Southern
reputation for excellent food was always good for the region’s
image, even in times when the South otherwise suffered from
severe
negative stereotyping, and it was something women took seriously.
A culture of creating and serving good food
rubbed off on everyone, even a woman who may not have been
predisposed to
culinary excellence. It wasn’t something she always did
alone, though. Even families of modest wealth often had cooks
or servants, if not slaves in the antebellum days. There were
enough hands to create elaborate meals that would make even
today’s foodies jealous.
One special attraction was beaten biscuits. Cookbook writer
Martha Stuart Smith lamented the demise of beaten biscuits
as far back as 1885, according to Grubb. Beaten biscuits required
constant and vigorous attack by the cook. The dough took such
a beating that no mere table was up to the task.
The recipe called for the cook to cut down a stout tree, preferably
oak or chestnut, and to plane the stump into a work surface.
A short-handled ax was also useful for working over the dough.
Presumably the stump was good for at least a few biscuit-making
episodes, Grubb says.
Although ax-wielding biscuit makers are rare these days, Grubb
says Americans are still dedicated to putting a lot of time
into the celebration.
“Rather than spending weeks saving eggs and storing
vegetables, we spend our time shopping,” he says. “Rather
than putting the burden of a large feast on one woman, we ask
everyone to bring a dish or two.”